Yay. I am not wanting to pick icons for other people, so will answer here:

1. Mary from P & P who is Talulah Riley, who I cast in my invented isurrendered drama Enigma House. It's great to write original stuff and have appropriate icons! (Made by ancientwhispers).

2. I was icon-making and in a silly mood? What can I say? I like this one because it amuses me, and also because via another person on my flist, it inspired daft fic by cersia5. Not bad for a flimsy icon.

3. Another I made. I like that you picked this one, because this remains my favourite icon by me. It's Carol Hawkins from Carry On Abroad. I did very little to it, it just worked out like this, and I love the crop and the two smiles making it an all-purpose happy-icon.

4. Made by redscharlach, whose mini-Who icons are just wonderful. I got this when A2A S3 was on, and I had to write a crossover for a meme. Well, that and I liked it, of course. It's also a useful one for when I'm being dim, which is reasonably frequent.

5. One of the many, many great DWJ quote icons made by catwalksalone. I took about all of them, but have narrowed them down to just a few. I like this one for its randomness. And being vaguely appropriate of LoTR comes up in conversation. And being a talking point. It's from one of the adult ones I don't remember well - Deep Secret or the other one, I forget, but obviously I need to find it and re-read it, clearly. :-)

Thank you! I liked your choices there.